Is There a Horde Tax in Kings of War 4.1? It Depends on How We Measure Value

Whenever I run combat simulations, I try to sanity-check my own models before trusting the output. For years, the core question has been simple: pound for pound, which units give you the most combat power for their points?

My first pass at the data looked wild: all 77 regiment-to-horde upgrades in the game seemed to lose efficiency when dividing Elo by points cost. It looked like definitive proof of a horde tax. But digging deeper revealed a fundamental flaw in the math—and fixing the yardstick blew that conclusion wide open.

TL;DR: The apparent horde tax depends on the yardstick. A better value measure makes regiment-to-horde upgrades look close to neutral relative to a size-adjusted baseline.

First, what does the simulator actually measure?

The current dataset contains 725 simulated unit profiles from 20 factions, including 574 troops, regiments, and hordes. Another 232 Individual-sized profiles were excluded from the Elo calculations. The analysis uses the 4.1 unit catalogue and a simulation run of a bit more than 7 million combats between units. The model runs units through one-on-one fights, then assigns Elo ratings. If you’ve seen Elo in chess, the idea is familiar: beating a stronger opponent earns a bigger rating gain than beating a weak one. Higher Elo means a unit performed better in these simulated duels.

There is an important limit here. A horde with 2,000 Elo is not a 2,000-point unit, and a 200-point unit should generally beat a 100-point unit. I want to know whether a unit is strong for what I paid, not just whether it wins a straight fight.

Earlier versions of my unit-efficiency analysis used Elo per point as one measure. Unfortunately, as I’ve thought through this more, I don’t think the analysis holds up: Elo doesn’t have a meaningful zero. Elo doesn’t scale linearly like points do, so the ratio between units shifts as the baseline shifts. Imagine a 100-point unit rated 1,000 Elo. That’s 10 Elo per point. Add 500 to every unit’s Elo rating without changing a single combat result, and it becomes 15 Elo per point. The battlefield hasn’t changed, but the supposed efficiency has. That’s a problem if we’re going to make claims about unit pricing.

A better measure, with an important catch

The revised model begins by estimating what Elo a unit would normally have given its points cost and size. In this dataset, an additional point of cost corresponds to about 5.55 Elo, after adjusting for size. From there I calculate three related measures:

  • Elo above expectation: the gap between a unit’s actual Elo and the rating predicted from its cost and size. Positive means it exceeded that fitted baseline.
  • Implied points: its listed points, plus the Elo gap converted back into points using that 5.55 Elo-per-point slope.
  • Points Value Ratio (PVR): implied points divided by listed points. A PVR of 1.20 means the profile’s rating maps to a price 20% higher on the model’s same-size relationship.

For readers who like the math:

Implied points = listed points + (actual Elo - expected Elo) / 5.546

PVR = implied points / listed points

The revised combined cost-effectiveness ranking puts equal weight on standardized PVR and standardized Elo above expectation. Those are two views of the same underlying Elo gap, so I don’t treat the combined ranking as a separate piece of evidence. The dataset also records an Elo-implied expected score versus par: a theoretical matchup with a typical unit of the same cost and size, not an actual game against an opponent. If you’ve seen my previous articles, you’ll recognize the combined cost-effectiveness score. This is that same number, but calculated using the better value metric.

Keep in mind this baseline is descriptive, not gospel: it tells you what Mantic currently charges for stats in 4.1, not whether that pricing is mathematically perfect.

What the data says about the “Horde Tax”

The dataset contains 77 matched regiment-and-horde pairs where the horde represents a double-footprint upgrade of the same unit. When we compare those pairs, the answer depends entirely on the measure.

MeasureRegiments MedianHordes MedianDifferenceHordes Higher
Raw Elo1,6432,096+45377 / 77 (100%)
Cost145 pts225 pts+80 pts (+55%)—
Elo / point (the old metric)11.39.3-2.00 / 77 (0%)
Elo above expectation-20+8+2849 / 77 (64%)
Points Value Ratio (PVR)0.981.01+0.0447 / 77 (61%)

Under the old Elo-per-point measure, every single horde looked less efficient. Under the size-adjusted model, that penalty disappears. Median Elo above expectation shifts from -20 to +8, and median PVR moves from 0.98 to 1.01. That is a modest difference, well within the noise of any single duel-based model. It is not evidence that hordes are secretly underpriced. What it does show is that the 77-for-77 “tax” was largely an artifact of an unsound calculation.

The real story is under the hood: 47 hordes gained value over their regiments, while 30 lost it. There’s no blanket ‘tax’ across the board—whether doubling your footprint is worth the points depends entirely on what the unit does.

UnitRegiment CostHorde CostRegiment PVRHorde PVRChange
Naiad Wyrmriders, Trident Realm1602450.861.10+0.24
Frostfang Cavalry, Northern Alliance1752650.861.08+0.23
Snow Trolls, Northern Alliance1402201.021.21+0.19
…
Trolls, Orcs1302051.070.94-0.13
Abyssal Horsemen, Forces of the Abyss1752700.960.81-0.15
Shield Wall, Kingdoms of Men1151851.030.87-0.16

The upgrade is not one uniform thing. The unit’s stat line and battlefield role matter a great deal.

Where the model sees value across unit types

The broader results are consistent with something I’ve seen in earlier army-efficiency rankings. The model is fond of tough units that hit hard. Median PVR is 1.13 for Monstrous Infantry (16 profiles) and 1.07 for both Heavy Infantry (62) and Large Infantry (115). Cavalry sits at 0.93 (75).

The shooting split is even clearer. The 192 profiles with a parsed ranged weapon have median PVR 0.89, against 1.05 for the other 533 profiles. That group includes hybrid shooters, and the other group isn’t necessarily pure melee. This is a descriptive split, not a controlled estimate of shooting’s value.

The simulator includes movement, shooting, and most special rules within its duels. It cannot fully price the value of threat projection, deployment, screening, chaff, support, and scenario play across a whole army. A unit doesn’t need to win a straight-up duel to earn its keep on the table. (I talked about this in my breakdown of 4E shooting—Is Shooting Dead in Kings of War 4th Edition?—chaff, screens, and threat projection win games without ever racking up massive duel stats). The 4E army categories show a similar pattern. Specialists and Support each have a median PVR of 1.04; Core is 1.02, Auxiliary 0.96, and Warlords 0.90 (note that this isn’t considering the value of inspiring, auras, or command orders). The fitted baseline adjusts for price and size, not category or battlefield job. These numbers don’t establish that Auxiliary or Warlord slots are bad investments. They tell us what those profiles accomplish in the simulated duel environment.

Here’s a useful example of the difference between strength and value:

ProfileCostDuel EloImplied pointsPVR
Order of the Abyssal Hunt, Basileans Horde3602,6053090.86
Coral Giant, Trident Realm Titan1952,0202661.36

The massive Order of the Abyssal Hunt is the highest-rated duel profile in this snapshot, but its price is high even by the fitted horde standard. The Coral Giant has a much lower raw Elo, yet comes in well above the model’s expectation for a 195-point Titan. That makes the Coral Giant the better relative-value example here. It doesn’t mean a Coral Giant beats the Order of the Abyssal Hunt horde in a duel.

What about factions?

Trident Realm has the highest median PVR in the current snapshot at 1.10 (33 profiles), followed by Ogres and Abyssal Dwarfs at 1.06 (47 and 34). At the other end are Nightstalkers 0.90 (24), Halflings 0.92 (35), and Ratkin 0.93 (27).

I would not turn that into a faction tier list. Twenty-three of the 24 simulated Nightstalker profiles have Mindthirst, which this simulator does not model (because inspiring is typically from other nearby leaders, not the unit itself). That’s a selected list of missing behavior, not a complete accounting of every rule or interaction the model may miss. We’ve also seen how easy it is for a unit-level efficiency ranking to miss what makes an army work. Ratkin were near the bottom of an earlier model while performing much better in competitive play. The difference between a good duel unit and a good tournament army is substantial.

Where I land

I still think these simulations are useful. They identify profiles that appear strong or weak for their cost in a controlled fight. They point us toward questions worth testing, such as why large-cavalry upgrades lag the baseline or why the same unit family scales differently across sizes. For the horde question, though, I don’t think we’ve established a universal tax. Nor have we shown that formation pricing is fair. We have shown that Elo per point can give a misleading picture of larger size units, while a size-adjusted value model answers a narrower question.

Bottom line: the ‘horde tax’ makes for great forum drama, but the math says it’s a myth.


Discover more from Data & Dice

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Scroll to Top