Introduction
Kings of War players love to debate balance. A faction wins a tournament and suddenly it’s “too strong.” A unit spikes damage in one game and it becomes “broken.” A local meta leans a certain way and people assume the entire game works like that. The problem is that most of these conversations are built on very small samples.
So over the past year I started building something I wish existed for the community: a clean dataset of real Kings of War games that we can actually analyze. Right now the tracker contains about 1,100 games from 4th Edition. Each record includes faction, matchup, list composition, and other attributes that let us explore what actually drives results on the table. The result is the Data & Dice Kings of War Dataset Explorer:
Instead of arguing from anecdotes, we can finally start asking questions like:
- Are some factions actually overperforming?
- Do certain list structures win more often?
- Do stats like Defense or Speed correlate with results?
Below I’ll walk through a few of the tools in the explorer and what the early data suggests.
Faction Win Rates

The first place most players look is faction performance. With more than a thousand recorded games, faction win rates start to stabilize. The noise from small tournaments fades and we can see broader trends.
The first surprise in the data is how tightly bunched most factions are: most factions cluster surprisingly close together. A couple run slightly hot, a couple lag behind, but the gap between the top and bottom is way narrower than forum doom-posting makes it sound.
If this 1,100-game sample holds up, early 4E balance is actually in pretty decent shape.
Archetype Performance

The dataset also categorizes armies by broad archetype. This lets us ask a more interesting question: does playstyle matter more than faction?
Early results suggest it might. Certain list structures consistently perform above average regardless of faction. Others tend to struggle even when attached to strong armies. This doesn’t mean any specific archetype is “solved” or dominant.
But it does suggest that list construction decisions may matter more than faction choice itself. For competitive players, that’s useful information.
The Stat Explorer

The feature I’m personally most excited about is the Stat Explorer. This tool lets you explore whether certain army characteristics correlate with better results. For example, you can test whether armies with:
- Higher average Defense
- Greater Speed
- More attacks
- Larger unit counts
actually perform better across hundreds of games.
The early takeaway is straightforward: no single stat guarantees wins. You can build around high Defense, raw Speed, or massive attack volume, but none of them carry a list on their own. That lines up with what experienced players already know: Kings of War is still a positioning and scenario game—clean movement and good trades beat a pretty statline every time.
Composition Comparison

The final major feature in the explorer is the composition comparison tool. This allows players to compare their army structure against thousands of lists already recorded in the dataset. It answers questions like:
- Is my list typical for this faction?
- Am I running more monsters or heroes than most players?
- How similar is my army to what the field usually brings?
For tournament preparation, this can be incredibly useful. Instead of guessing what “normal” looks like, you can actually see where your list sits relative to the broader meta.
Why This Matters
Magic has massive stat databases, chess has centuries of records, and esports track every click. Miniature wargaming usually gets stuck arguing over whatever happened at the top table last Saturday. The goal here isn’t to declare the meta solved or prove anyone wrong—it’s simply to make better questions possible.
The point is just to give all of us real numbers to look at instead of relying on gut feelings and forum arguments.
Where This Goes Next
The dataset is still growing. More games mean better confidence in the patterns we’re starting to see. Future updates will likely include:
- Matchup analysis between factions
- Player skill adjustments
- Event-level meta trends
- More detailed list construction metrics
If you want to explore the data yourself, start here: https://kow-dataset.web.app
And if you have event data available, consider contributing. I’m particularly looking for events where we have: lists for all players and game-by-game results. You can reach out or share datasets through the forum thread here: https://www.kowforum.com/t/data-and-dice/4354
More data makes the project better for everyone. So if you’re a TO or someone who tracks events, I’d love to hear from you.
TL;DR:
The Data & Dice dataset now includes over 1,100 Kings of War 4th Edition games. Early analysis suggests faction balance is tighter than many players expect, list structure may matter more than faction choice, and individual army stats are weaker predictors of success than positioning and scenario play.
Discover more from Data & Dice
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

